Clint Van Zandt - former FBI Criminal Profiler, Hostage Negotiator, and current TV and News Media Crime Analyst

{"contentId":"2618023","authorDomain":"clintvanzandt"}

Another Sunday Morning Murder

Investigator with believed murder weapon used to kill 8 and wound 3.

PineLake Health & Rehab

The Face of a Killer -
Robert Stewart

The murder count, like the spring temperature, continues to rise in America, this as a 45-year-old gunman walked into a rural North Carolina nursing home at 10 AM Sunday morning with multiple firearms and began shooting. Before he was shot by a police officer he had fired dozens of rounds, killing 8 and wounding 3, to include the police officer who traded shots with him in the halls of the nursing home. This latest incident of mass murder (3 or more victims at the same location at the same time) follows the March 8 church shooting in Maryville, IL where the popular pastor was murdered before his congregation, and the March 10 shooting that spanned two Alabama communities in which 10 were killed, to include the shooter. The next day a teenager entered his former high school in Germany and killed 12, so this kind of crime is not simply a byproduct of America's old west as some suggest. All of these shootings took place where the shooter likely believed he would be the only person with a gun and would have all the time he needed to complete his terrible act.

For many, though, the home is also their workplace, especially for stay-at-home mothers. Such appeared to be the case, unfortunately, on Sunday night in a Santa Clara, CA home when an Indian man using two handguns shot and killed 5 people. The victims included three children, a man and a woman. A woman believed to be the shooter's wife sustained multiple gun shot wounds, and then the shooter took his own life. Police described the tragic event as "a family on family, murder suicide." What personal demons must have possessed the shooter in this case?

What the latest N.C. nursing home workplace shooting and so many similar situations seem to have in common is that the shooter appeared to have great anger and rage, and may well have believed that he was going to die, going out in a blaze that would somehow even the score in life, one in which such shooters may believe themselves far behind. The former wife of the North Carolina killer, Robert Stewart, indicated he was angry and violent at times. While they had not spoken since their divorce 8 years ago, he had tried reaching out to her this past week through relatives, indicating that he had cancer and was preparing to "go away." It has been reported that the gunman's ex-wife was working at the site of the murders, The Pinelake Health and Rehab Center, and had barricaded herself in a room while the shootings were taking place. Her presence suggests that this was not a random act of violence and the gunman's likely target was his former spouse, with his anger acted out against nursing home residents. This is, unfortunately, not atypical for acts of domestic violence that far too often are carried out in the workplace.

Some shooters go into a workplace as it is one location where they can be assured that they can find their current/former significant other or another target of their wrath, this while others may want to make a "statement" that will forever impact on their former associate or loved one. What remains clear through the acid-like smoke of gunfire in these terrible incidents is that anyone who gets in the way of the gunman and his intended target becomes a secondary target. Someone like Jerry Avant, a male nurse at the facility who was allegedly shot 27 times by Stewart (perhaps suggesting a 12 gauge shotgun firing 00 buckshot with nine .33 caliber pellets in each shell) as he tried to protect his patients, noting the dead, other than Avant, were between 78 and 98 years of age. These victims were hardly able to stand between the gunman and his intended target(s), and, in fact, became the innocent victims of his uncontrollable rage, as they were simply in the wrong place at the wrong time.

We have learned many lessons since the April 1999 shooting at Colorado's Columbine HS in which two students murdered 12, wounded 23 and committed suicide. We saw these terrible lessons put into action when authorities, unlike the Columbine massacre, quickly entered a classroom building on the Virginia Tech campus in April 2007 to stop a raging student gunman who was still able to murder 32 and wound 23 before committing suicide, this representing the greatest single act of mass murder by one person with a firearm in U.S. history. Police now understand "the active shooter" and know they simply do not have the time to put together a dedicated assault plan when people are actively being shot and killed. They must enter the affected facility and go directly for the gunman, engaging him to force him to place his attention and his firepower on them, thereby saving lives. This is what 25-year-old police officer Justin Garner did as he engaged Stewart in a gun battle, wounding the shooter with one .40 cal shot to his chest, stopping his murderous rampage. Officer Garner, who was hit 3 times in the leg by Stewart, probably never imagined being involved in such a situation while working for the small town of Carthage, population 1,800. We need true heros in this country and what this 4 1/2 year veteran police officer and nurse Jerry Avant did to save the lives of others was surely heroic! In war time they might both be awarded the Medal of Honor.

My experience is that there are always people sitting on the edge of their own personal psychological abyss, waiting for the right time to jump, perhaps taking others with them on their mission from hell. For some shooters, though, the murder and mayhem they create may be their answer to their own personal problem, their way to say something, and, perhaps, to end something; like their life. While many will say of the Robert Stewarts of the world, "he just cracked," "there was no indication that he would act out in this manner," I believe differently. I think there are always signs, outward manifestations of the rage that is boiling just below such a person's psychological surface. These clues, these cracks in their personalities and their changes in behavior can be subtle at times, and can be overlooked, ignored, or simply missed by those around the shooter-to-be. And, in the case of each of these shooters over the years, someone like Cho at Virginia Tech, why not the week before, the month before, or the following month; why did he choose to act out on that particular day?

I believe that there is always order in what we otherwise describe as chaos, or in the case of humans, chaotic behavior. This in regard to the random, senseless, and chaotic behavior that we see in a person who commits a mass murder in a school, church or nursing home; we just need to find what the individual cares about and how he goes about resolving his own personal conflicts. The cracks and fissures in our own personalities can weaken us to the point where any of us could be capable of committing a terrible act, but we choose to control that impulse; this, as we tell ourselves, because we are socialized. Some, however, due to a number of different reasons either lose control of their impulsive behavior, or are able to justify their acts as they blame others for what they are about to unleash on them.

A mass murder may take his own lives as such completes the personal destruction he may already believe has taken place, while others may simply not want to be subjected to the questions of an ordered society. Robert Stewart will likely have some reason to explain, to justify why he gunned down so many senior citizens who were simply living out the last days of their life in peace; something that may have eluded him. There will be some order to what he did, but for the rest of us, we are continually challenged to understand what to most in the unexplainable; man's inhumanity to man.

{"contentId":"2618023","authorDomain":"clintvanzandt"}
  • Enjoy this article? Help vote it up the 'Vine.
{"commentId":6230055,"authorDomain":"cynthiakilgore60"}

Hi Clint,

Excellent article. Chilling. I agree that few of these monsters have operated without giving prior clues. While I am in no way blaming media, do you think that fewer of these mass murders would occur if they were operating in a vacuum? Surely the murderers know they will become infamous. Is that part of the allure with this type of extreme violent behavior?

{"commentId":6230055,"threadId":"541597","contentId":"2618023","authorDomain":"cynthiakilgore60"}
    Reply#1 - Mon Mar 30, 2009 2:16 PM EDT
    {"commentId":6231357,"authorDomain":"clintvanzandt"}

    Cindy,

    I think what these mass murders present is a blueprint for irrational behavior, one that is, unfortunately, copied and repeated over and over again. I agree, though, that the 24/7 coverage that the media provides such stories gets them out to be seen and copied.

    Be Safe,

    CVZ

    {"commentId":6231357,"threadId":"541597","contentId":"2618023","authorDomain":"clintvanzandt"}
      Reply#2 - Mon Mar 30, 2009 3:29 PM EDT
      {"commentId":6231598,"authorDomain":"motherlovemelon"}

      It's truly a shame more of these gunmen don't survive their killing sprees, not only so they may be put to justice, but more importantly, so they may be studied, even dissected (to include the literal meaning of the word), to get a better understanding of the workings of their minds.

      {"commentId":6231598,"threadId":"541597","contentId":"2618023","authorDomain":"motherlovemelon"}
        Reply#3 - Mon Mar 30, 2009 3:40 PM EDT
        {"commentId":6232257,"authorDomain":"clintvanzandt"}

        mLm...,

        In the case of the NC murders, the shooter has survived, though the answers he may provide to investigators will never answer the "why" of his actions. To me it comes down to a matter of choice, and far too many make bad choices. In the case of depressed men, they are far less likely to express their need for help and far more likely to self medicate with drugs and alcohol, therefore masking their true problem, and far more likely than women to die by a suicide related act, in reality 4 to 1, this while statistics show that 8 out of 10 cases of severe depression respond positively to treatment.

        Best,

        CVZ

        {"commentId":6232257,"threadId":"541597","contentId":"2618023","authorDomain":"clintvanzandt"}
          #3.1 - Mon Mar 30, 2009 4:14 PM EDT
          Reply
          {"commentId":6235624,"authorDomain":"mareleigh"}

          I'm one of the local residence of Moore County.  I can honestly say.. we are all in a state of shock.  Our DA advised that information pertaining to the case, she felt need to be left unsaid.  Having been here, part of the community. I have my own opinion.  I know the man claimed to have cancer, and planned on going away for a long time.  I know, that his first ex wife was an employee at the rest home.  Why would he walk in and begin just a killing spree, I thing it will be the people in a specific unit, possible patients his exwife worked with. And a  personal crime.  Was he depressed?  it was noted that he had gained a great deal of weight, and that he had problems with his temperment. Intense Anger, throwing things when he did not get his way.. This information was reported by his second ex wife.  Yes, he has been removed to Raleigh..  The elderly patients that were shot,  have family close at hand, With the Nursing Home they were in, their families may well have been in that area for many genertions.  I'm split between Anger and Fear.

          {"commentId":6235624,"threadId":"541597","contentId":"2618023","authorDomain":"mareleigh"}
            Reply#4 - Mon Mar 30, 2009 7:24 PM EDT
            {"commentId":6235986,"authorDomain":"clintvanzandt"}

            mlee,

            I am sorry for your personal and your community loss in this matter. Part of your fear is the realization that terrible crimes can happen anywhere, even in small, rural communities such as yours.

            Depression strikes 4 times the number of men vs. women, and although 80% of depressed people can be helped with counseling and medication, men are far more likely to avoid asking for, seeking, and accepting help. Signs of depression include a drastic change in weight, poor anger management skills, and financial and personal problems. Men are far more likely to self medicate with drugs and alcohol, thereby masking their problems.

            There is much to be learned concerning this tragedy, but part of of education may come from the shooter himself. We are not too different though, and men in similar situations, when they appear to go after their current or former significant other in the workplace, can displace their rage and anger on coworkers and, in this case, patients. Some men have murdered their children to devastate their current or former wife, while in a case like this, the shooter may have murdered the patients out of his anger and rage for not finding his target, and/or to punish his ex, giving her something to remember him by for the rest of her life.

            This was an exceptionally murderous weekend in America, with mass murder shootings in NC, California, and Mass. Communities such as yours never really heal, and the innocence lost can never be returned, but you can learn to live with the pain, and, perhaps, all begin to look further for the tell tale signs of depression in another that could suggest he is building up to violence against others and/or himself. This in and of itself helps the healing process, knowing you can do something to try to prevent any future act like this.

            I wrote a recent article entitled "Bad Financial Times = Terrible Personal Decisions...," that can be found at http://clintvanzandt.newsvine.com/_news/2008/10/08/1971692-bad-financial-times-terrible-personal-decisions

            The above discusses depression, suicide, and what we can do to help others facing such emotional challenges.

            Best to you and yours,

            CVZ

            {"commentId":6235986,"threadId":"541597","contentId":"2618023","authorDomain":"clintvanzandt"}
              #4.1 - Mon Mar 30, 2009 7:51 PM EDT
              Reply
              {"commentId":6275382,"authorDomain":"roover685"}

              Clint -- a very insightful article. I understand depression. I understand suicide. I have a hard time understanding how someone who intends to take their own life decides that they will take other lives too. When I think of people who are both depressed and suicidal, I think of them turning inward, losing energy, giving up. It seems hard to imagine that they would have the energy and focus to plan such a rampage, but obviously they do. And if this man did indeed have cancer, it is so hard to fathom that instead of feeling like making the best of his remaining days, he decides to use what energy he has left to kill others and himself. I know you talk about his rage and "going out" in a memorable way -- but is there anything else that you can offer that further explains this behavior?

              Thanks.

              bc

              {"commentId":6275382,"threadId":"541597","contentId":"2618023","authorDomain":"roover685"}
                Reply#5 - Thu Apr 2, 2009 2:47 AM EDT
                {"canLink":false,"threadId":"541597","isPrivate":false}
                Leave a Comment:
                You're in Easy Mode. If you prefer, you can use XHTML Mode instead.
                As a new user, you may notice a few temporary content restrictions. Click here for more info.
                {"threadId":"541597","contentId":"2618023"}
                Start TrackingStart Tracking
                Stop TrackingStop Tracking
                RSS feedSyndicate this contentRecent Articles & Seeds
                Clint Van Zandt's Latest Comments
                Comments & Feedback
                – Show More